Rankings

Best Bakeries in Columbus, Ohio

Macarons, sticky buns, sourdough and hometown donuts, ranked by what comes out of the oven.

Photo: Pistacia Vera

Best Bakeries in Columbus, Ohio

We built this bakery list from the menus, price lists, hours pages and about pages each shop publishes, all reread on October 30 and 31. To make the cut a bakery has to bake in its own kitchen, sell to walk-in customers and keep its hours current online. The ranking rewards range and craft we can see on paper: laminated pastry and gluten-free options at Pistacia Vera, hearth bread at Dan the Baker, an all-vegan cooperative case, and old family donut counters that have outlasted generations. Placement weighs how much a menu shows beyond the basics. We have not tasted from these cases for this update, and none of the shops were phoned.

7 bakerys

2026 Winners Picks by Bart Rian

2026 Best Overall
2026 Best Overall
Open gold Pistacia Vera box holding a row of yellow, cream, caramel and pink macarons

Photo: Pistacia Vera

Pistacia Vera

French pastry shop German Village

German Village patisserie with gluten-free macarons, butter croissants and croissant-bun sandwiches seven days a week.

541 S 3rd St, Columbus, OH 43215

  • Why it was picked:
  • Gluten-free macarons at $2.50 each
  • Rye croissant bun on the smoked salmon sandwich
  • Open daily, 7 a.m. on weekdays

Why Pistacia Vera Is Our Best Overall Pick

Pistacia Vera on Third Street in German Village marks its menu with gluten-free, nut-free and egg-free codes, and its macarons, at $2.50 each, carry the gluten-free tag. A classic butter croissant is $4.50, and the croissant dough reappears as the bun for savory plates such as a $14.50 rye croissant with cold-smoked salmon. Quiches like potato raclette run $13.50, and a salted pistachio latte is $12. The shop opens at 7 a.m. on weekdays and 8 a.m. on weekends, closing at 3 p.m. daily.

Checked Oct 31, 2026, owner site and menu

  • Gluten-free macarons at $2.50 each
  • Rye croissant bun on the smoked salmon sandwich
  • Open daily, 7 a.m. on weekdays

2026 Finalists

Schneider's Bakery storefront on State Street with a scalloped awning, a lit open sign and script lettering on the window
2026 Finalist

Photo: Schneider's Bakery

Schneider's Bakery

Hometown donut bakery Westerville

Uptown Westerville's donut counter has opened at 6 a.m. for more than six decades, with Long Johns, double chocolate cookies and birthday cakes.

6 S State St, Westerville, OH 43081

Why was this picked?

  • Opens at 6 a.m. Monday through Saturday
  • Long Johns, twists and cream-filled donuts
  • Uptown State Street storefront for six decades

Checked Oct 31, 2026, owner site and menu