Close view of a Kittie's Cakes cinnamon roll with thick white icing on a cooling rack

Cake bakery and cafe Worthington $

Kittie's Cakes

Name: Kittie's Cakes
Address: 693 High St, Worthington, OH 43085, OH, US
Telephone: (614) 992-2899
Price range: $

Kittie's tops its hot chocolate with marshmallows made in house, a sweet stop on Old Worthington's High Street.

693 High St, Worthington, OH 43085

Worthington cafe open daily 7 a.m. to 4 p.m.

Visit Site (614) 992-2899 Own this business? Get your media kit

Awards

2026 Finalist Best Bakeries in Columbus, Ohio 2026 Finalist Best Hot Chocolate in Columbus, Ohio

Why Kittie's Cakes why was this picked

Kittie's Cakes tops its hot chocolate with marshmallows made in house, the only cup on this list with a homemade topping. Its Worthington location, 693 High St, keeps 7 a.m. to 4 p.m. hours every day, as is the Bexley cafe on East Main Street, while the German Village bakery on South Third Street, open Tuesday through Sunday mornings, does the baking. Coffee drinkers can order espresso drinks, tea comes from Blue Turtle Tea Company and matcha from Potion Matcha Bar.

House-made marshmallows on top
Steps from the Worthington Village Green
Open daily in Worthington

Know before you go

Kittie's Cakes runs a cafe at 693 High St in Worthington and ranks sixth on our best bakeries list.

Locations

Worthington cafe: 693 High St, (614) 992-2899. Bexley cafe: 2424 E. Main St, (614) 929-5000. German Village bakery: 495 S. Third St, (614) 754-8828.

Coffee and espresso come from One Line Coffee, and tea is from Blue Turtle Tea Company.

The hot chocolate with house-made marshmallows puts it fifth on our best hot chocolate list.

Parking: Old Worthington street parking and public lots off High Street.
Reservations: Walk in; order quiche by Thursday for weekend pickup.
Tip: The German Village bakery at 495 S. Third St opens Tuesday through Sunday from 7 a.m. to 1 p.m. if you want the source.

In the news

A white mug of hot chocolate topped with a swirl of whipped cream and a dusting of cocoa, on a saucer with a doily and a spoon

Food & DrinkGrandviewOct 30

New List: Best Hot Chocolate in Columbus

Five cafes ranked for the cup itself, the toppings, price and evening hours, with Chocolate Cafe on Northwest Boulevard at No. 1. Status: Live on site.

Bart Rian1 min read

A sunny brick street corner in German Village with two-story red brick buildings, utility poles and parked cars along the curb

Food & DrinkGerman VillageOct 29

New List: Best Bakeries in Columbus

Seven bakeries ranked on what comes out of the oven, from German Village macarons to Uptown Westerville donuts, with Pistacia Vera at No. 1. Status: Live on site.

Bart Rian1 min read