Barley's Brewing food spread with pierogies and house beer
2026 Finalist

Brewpub Arena District $$

Barley's Brewing Company

Ale House #1 on N High with cheddar pierogi platters and fried pierogi next to house beer.

467 N High St, Columbus, OH 43215

Confirm lunch and dinner hours on barleysbrewing.com for Ale House #1.

Awards

Why Barley's Brewing Company why was this picked

Barley's Ale House #1 lands second for cheddar and potato pierogi that still share the menu with kielbasa, bratwurst, brown butter, and sour cream, plus a fried pierogi tossed in wing sauce when you want heat. It is the Arena District brewpub pierogi stop across from the Convention Center, not the old Smokehouse. Pint glasses and a mahogany bar make it an easy pre-event plate.

  • Pierogi and Sausage Platter and fried pierogi on current menus
  • Ale House #1 only at 467 N High St
  • Arena District brewpub next to Convention Center traffic

Know before you go

Barley's Brewing Company Ale House #1 anchors Arena District High Street across from the Greater Columbus Convention Center with house beer and pierogi plates that still share the menu. It is second on our best pierogies list for the Pierogi and Sausage Platter and fried pierogi options. Do not confuse this address with the former Smokehouse on Dublin Road.

Cheddar and potato pierogi with kielbasa, bratwurst, brown butter, and sour cream keep the plate hearty before a show or convention block. Confirm the phone at (614) 228-2537 on the official contact page if directories disagree.

Parking
Arena District street and garage parking near N High and the Convention Center.
Reservations
Walk-ins common; larger groups should call (614) 228-2537.
Tip
This profile is Ale House #1 at 467 N High only. Ask for the Pierogi and Sausage Platter or sauteed cheddar pierogi if you want the classic onion finish.